Triage objections into fatal / scope / weak and plan the revision
Classifies each objection from any critique activity as fatal, scope-limiting, or weak, then proposes the specific amendment to the thesis or framework for each.
In / outConsolidated objection list → triage classification (fatal/scope/weak) per objection with proposed specific amendment for each
You might say…
“I have twelve objections from three different people and I don't know which ones should actually change the argument.”
What it does
Takes the consolidated set of challenges from any critique activity and classifies each objection as fatal (claim must narrow, reverse, or be abandoned), scope (needs a qualification or boundary), or weak (can be pre-empted), then proposes the specific amendment to the thesis or framework. Used as the synthesis step that turns gathered feedback into a concrete plan to sharpen the idea itself.
Trigger: Use as the synthesis step after any critique activity — turning a pile of gathered feedback into a concrete revision plan.
Recognise the problem?
The primitives are the commodity part. The fastest next step is a conversation about composing them into something that works for you.
Start a conversation